Zuegel, a 31-year-old software engineer raised in the heart of Silicon Valley, arrived in Cloverdale two years ago with fanciful renderings for a village with upwards of 600 new apartments and homes on the city's eastern edge. She gave it the name Esmeralda, and in this tight-knit town of just under 9,000 people, the idea stoked both excitement and alarm.

Zuegel's connections to the global center for tech innovation inspired comparisons to billionaires talking about forming their own governments and living on Mars. Zuegel has said that's not her world, but a place like Cloverdale could be. A live music festival runs on Friday nights all summer, shutting down the boulevard and drawing crowds of local families, retirees and neighbors. Banners hang on light posts celebrating active military service members.

This summer, Cloverdale will begin formally considering Zuegel's Esmeralda development proposal, an idea that has already consumed two years of public debate: Whether a long-dormant, 266-acre former industrial mill site along the Russian River should become an entirely new walkable neighborhood with housing, a hotel, an amphitheater, shops and cafes, playgrounds, parks and trails.

It's been nearly a half-century since utility poles were cut and treated with chemicals on the site. Since then, the land has undergone soil excavation, treatment injections and other forms of remediation. Various plans to transform the languishing but prime riverfront land have been taken up and abandoned, including a proposed destination resort with commercial space, homes, an equestrian center plus an 18-hole golf course. The city said yes two decades ago, but the project never moved beyond a concept.

[...]

The Esmeralda Land Co. would build housing at a time when nearly every California city is desperate for more. It would build municipal water tanks, public trails and a park - all gifts to the city. And the project would generate an annual fiscal surplus of $2.3 million, at a minimum, according to a draft financial impact analysis they're producing for the city - to replenish Cloverdale city coffers and end an ongoing budget deficit.

[...]

To supporters, Esmeralda is a rare chance to bring a major jolt of new energy to Cloverdale, where downtown businesses often struggle to stay open past late afternoon. To skeptics, it risks disrupting a careful balance in a community threatened by drought, wildfire and economic strain.

Esmeralda Land Co.'s plans, at least these initial concepts, are ambitious but not that radical compared to other neighborhood buildouts. About 40 miles south on Highway 101, Rohnert Park's SOMO Village has been remaking a former Hewlett-Packard manufacturing campus into a 176-acre mixed-use neighborhood. Approved for 1,750 homes, the site already has apartments, offices, a brew pub and a school, with more residential construction underway.

Sonoma County's northernmost city must plan for 335 new homes by 2031 or face state penalties. Cloverdale had already reached about 70% of its affordable housing goals at the end of 2024, according to city data, but was further behind with market rate housing.

Esmeralda would push the city far beyond that mark.

Zuegel's company has secured the option to buy the property, which comes with those entitlements approved about 20 years ago to build a resort with 235 homes, an 18-hole golf course, equestrian center plus commercial space. But they are applying to revise the plan and allow for a more connected, public-oriented enclave with a 200-room hotel, 200-unit senior housing complex, 405 market rate dwellings (a mix of houses and town homes), 22,000 square feet of retail space and 17,500 square feet of office space plus 168 acres for open space and recreation.

Zuegel said they have the financial backing of 19 individual and family investors, most from the Bay Area, including some from Sonoma County. The Esmeralda Land Co. is not disclosing their identities; Zuegel said they wish to remain anonymous.