1. ← Home
Login
We are all playable characters
~opinion~philosophy
asteriskmag.substack.com 2 days ago

Summary

From the article:

In both narratives and lives, one thing happens after another, and meaning is sought from the progression of events. Perhaps for this reason, European intellectual tradition has consistently recounted lives as a story, presenting them in a developmental manner that builds toward some “point.” In contrast, other traditions, including in early China, reached for nature’s recurring cycles — rather than teleological linear progression — to understand life’s rhythms in work and rest, growth and decay, and the rise and fall of family fortunes.

[...]

From here, it is a short step to arrive at the 20th-century philosophers and psychologists who theorized that stories are crucial to self-understanding, if not to identity altogether. The psychologist Jerome Bruner argued that “[o]ur precommitment about the nature of a life is that it is a story.” His ideas, also explored by Alasdair MacIntyre, Paul Ricoeur, Marya Schechtman, and Daniel Dennett, among others, have been influential both in academic discussions of identity and selfhood and in broader culture. A quarter into the 21st century, we still live in a narrative culture where it is natural to think of ourselves as protagonists of the story of our lives, periods of our lives as chapters, and friends as side characters.

But narrative logic is limited by its temporal structure: What makes lives and stories seem meaningful is the way events accrue and connect. The problem with this, according to philosopher Elisabeth Camp, is that stories are beholden to their ending for meaning.

We can, of course, tell the story of our lives while in the middle of it, but the meaning of any event is open to revision until the story is over. An early tragedy could be a formative moment that provides someone with the resilience they need to succeed later, or it could be a harbinger of difficulties that will continue to plague a life. To think of a life as a story, then, is to hold meaning, value, and identity in limbo until the end.

[...]

Gaming terms and concepts aren’t new, either. Tabletop role-playing games like Dungeons & Dragons supplied concepts like NPC, experience points, quests, and abilities, though these terms remained technical throughout the ’70s and ’80s. As gaming went online and massively multiplayer online games proliferated in the ’90s and 2000s, gaming vocabulary contributed to a subculture with its own dialect; this is when terms like “noob,” “loot,” “camping,” and “grinding” became popular.

Now this language has gone mainstream. The Merriam-Webster dictionary added “level up” in 2022; “NPC” has become conspicuous in political meme culture; and just last year, Merriam-Webster added a separate entry for “side quest” in its Slang Dictionary, as a Gen Z term that refers to anything secondary to the main pursuit.

There are a variety of reasons for this proliferation: the growth of technology that makes gamification easy, a widespread culture of optimization, and several generations that have now grown up with video games. An underappreciated explanation for the growing appeal of these concepts, however, is that games provide a new mode of engagement that isn’t possible with stories.

[...]

Many games are narrative in structure: Pandemic Legacy and Dungeons & Dragons require player choices that determine events and tell a story. Still, games that combine narrative and ludic elements lean on player action. There is always a “now” in games that requires a move. In a story, someone is represented as making choices; in a game, someone must actually make choices. In a game, we’re simultaneously the first-person experiencer and the interpreter-planner of what is going on, privy to statistics like health points and the time left for the round even while enjoying the game world. In stories, we toggle between the character living a life and the narrator or author who tells us about the life, but games allow the integration of the two roles.

[...]

In a narrative framework, answering the question “Who am I?” requires looking at what happened in my life and what that says about the person I am. In a ludic framework, asking the question “Who am I?” involves asking what my task is and how good I am at it. In a narrative-ludic framework, to ask “Who am I?” is to ask for a role, a character type that would tell me how I am supposed to act. Modern character types — Karen, Chad, girlboss, tradwife — are narrative concepts transformed through ludic influence.

[...]

Characters are playable: They provide a context that makes certain actions, but not others, make sense within it. Some choices count as progress while others count as failure. Once someone takes up “Horse Girl” as a role, an array of actions becomes newly salient as moves that “count” — talking about horses, spending the weekend riding, buying horse stickers — and the role gives those moves a center of gravity that coheres them into a recognizable way of being. The tradwife type comes with a preloaded set of values — domesticity, nuclear family, traditional gender roles — and a set of instructions that tells someone what to wear, what to buy, and how to behave. With a narrative, a character’s values are revealed through the course of the story. But the tradwife character shows you up front what counts as playing her well.

[...]

Another worry lurking here is related to what Nguyen calls “value capture.” Games define what counts as success, and character types can do the same socially. If it weren’t for already existing worldviews and values compressed into character types that we can try on, we would have to customize our own set of commitments and tastes to reflect who we are. The malleable nature of character types helps only slightly since they tend to offer simplified values, such as looking or dressing a certain way.