Summary
From the article:
We’re talking, of course, about utility wildfire liability reform. Outgoing Gov. Gavin Newsom failed to broker a deal with lawmakers at the end of this year’s legislative session to protect the state’s major utilities from the potentially ruinous liabilities they face from fires sparked by their power lines.
Shares of the parent companies of Pacific Gas & Electric and Southern California Edison dropped precipitously on that news. PG&E, still recovering from a 2019 bankruptcy after its equipment started the Camp Fire in 2018, responded by announcing a “strategic review” that included postponing about $2 billion in work planned for 2027.
Last month, PG&E sent letters to some 25,000 customers warning them to expect delays in getting grid connections. Estimates range from one to six months for connecting housing developments and office buildings to “2027 and beyond” for city and county transportation and public works projects.
Among those facing undetermined delays are more than 60 renewable and storage projects scheduled to be online by 2030 — which could add at least 15 gigawatts of capacity, according to a PG&E spokesperson.
This compounds the already substantial delays for clean energy developers that have been struggling to get connected to California’s transmission grid. In fact, it could undermine the financial prospects of a lot of solar projects, Jan Smutny-Jones, CEO of the Independent Energy Producers Association, said at an Oct. 28 hearing of the California Assembly Utilities and Energy Committee.
Adding to the urgency is the fact that solar developers are under the gun to complete work by 2030 or lose out on federal tax credits thanks to revised deadlines in the tax and spending megabill passed by Republicans last year. “Miss that date, game over. It’s at least a 30% increase in the cost of those goods,” he said.
The new delays also threaten California’s goal of building 6 GW of new clean energy and storage by 2032. If projects can’t stay on schedule, the state may be forced to once again put off retiring more than 3 GW of aging, polluting coastal gas plants, Smutny-Jones said.
[...]
This is truly a problem from hell, and I won’t pretend to know how to solve it. California’s unique inverse condemnation legal doctrine, which holds utilities liable for fires caused by their equipment even absent utility negligence, makes every power line a potentially business-ending risk. At the same time, utilities do need to be held responsible when they are negligent. PG&E was found guilty of involuntary manslaughter in 2020 for causing the Camp Fire.
[...]
Southern California Edison now faces a jury trial to determine its liability for billions of dollars of damages caused by January’s Eaton Fire, which could deplete the state’s $21 billion wildfire fund. Wildfire victims and consumer advocates outraged at the idea of the state intervening to limit utility shareholder payouts see PG&E’s $2 billion in spending cutbacks as a form of blackmail.
But a state-mandated report issued this summer makes clear that failing to fix the status quo will leave utilities at risk of financial collapse — and that’s a direct threat to climate progress and energy affordability. I fear things are going to get uglier before we find any compromises. We may need a plan C and D along with a plan B.