1. ← Home
Login
Israel changes crocodiles legal status in push for Ben-Gvir's 'crocodile prison'
~offbeatisraelcrocodilesprisons
www.jpost.com 4 weeks agoTildes

Summary

From the article:

Environmental Protection Minister Idit Silman declared the Nile crocodile a “cultivated wild animal” in a move intended to allow the Israel Prison Service to station crocodiles around prisons, despite opposition from her ministry’s legal adviser and the Israel Nature and Parks Authority, Ynet reported on Thursday.

Silman issued the declaration to enable National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir to establish his proposed “crocodile prison.” Pressure was placed on the Israel Nature and Parks Authority several months ago to allow the National Security Ministry to receive crocodiles from Hamat Gader and position them around prisons holding security prisoners. The program was expected to be piloted at Ketziot Prison.

[...]

In the past, crocodile farming has led to numerous problems, including incidents of crocodiles escaping into the wild and risks to human life. Former environmental protection minister Gilad Erdan ended the practice following a recommendation from the advisory committee of the Nature and Parks Authority’s plenum.

Silman effectively decided to revive a dead letter in the Wildlife Protection Law. In practice, however, she created a new category: a cultivated wild animal kept for security purposes. Her declaration stated that the animals would be held by a security organization, subject to the environmental protection minister’s approval of the security need.

[...]

The Environmental Protection Ministry’s legal adviser, attorney Neta Drori, wrote to Silman last month that there was insufficient professional and factual evidence to proceed as the minister wished. She added that there was no known professional precedent for using crocodiles as a security measure at modern prisons, contrary to the Prison Service’s claim that they had been used for this purpose in the US and South America.

[...]

“Although Prison Service officials said they are aware of and prepared to ensure the animals’ physical welfare, among other things based on their experience with dogs, the organization apparently has no expertise in raising dangerous wild animals such as crocodiles,” she wrote.

[...]

Silman decided to disregard the legal adviser’s position, arguing that a senior professional official at the Nature and Parks Authority had said the authority did not oppose the Prison Service’s initiative and that an approved framework used in the past already existed.

Several weeks ago, Ben-Gvir and Silman met with the Nature and Parks Authority’s director-general and the Environmental Protection Ministry’s legal adviser and said they wanted crocodiles to be placed around a prison. The legal adviser made clear that this could not be done and that there was no legal authority to approve it, but Silman persisted.